Please help me pick!!

Posted here before about the dress I originally bought (marked in photos), but I was having some dress regret so I decided to try on some more! I have already returned my original dress and I am leaning towards dress 1, but am worried it doesn’t match my venue (pictured in last two photos). I don’t know if the material seems too heavy or if the lace looks old fashioned, and would love people’s thoughts!! It’s also the most expensive dress out of the ones pictured, but still within my budget. I’m just not sure if it’s that much nicer than the other dresses to warrant the extra cost.