Why is Tiffany's (S10) plea so imfamous?

As a disclaimer: I have not watched Season 10 of Hell's Kitchen. Most of what I say here is based on information from clips,

I'm mostly sure that you probably know about the notorious plea made by Tiffany at the Final 11, where she states that she cares like a 9 to Chef Ramsay. I'm just wondering why this is considered by many to be among the worst pleas in HK history.

I get that chefs should be giving it their all, but to me, caring a 10 out of 10 is pretty much sacrificing everything for Hell's Kitchen, which makes me think of Michael (S11). He gave up watching the birth of his kid to go to HK, which was frowned upon my Chef Ramsay and the audience, so clearly people don't want chefs to sacrifice everything for this.

Even in a mematic way, it doesn't make sense, considering how high a 9 is. If someone says, they like something "like a 9" they generally have a string opinion on that thing, which is the opposite of what the original clip is supposedly meant to represent. Plus there are much worse pleas like when Scott (S7) says he'll fuck everyone over. or Tony (S6) saying he likes to make things taste good, both of which are infinitely more funny.

Maybe I'm just dumb, but I don't understand why so many gravitated to this plea out of all of them.

As a disclaimer: I have not watched Season 10 of Hell's Kitchen. Most of what I say here is based on information from clips,

I'm mostly sure that you probably know about the notorious plea made by Tiffany at the Final 11, where she states that she cares like a 9 to Chef Ramsay. I'm just wondering why this is considered by many to be among the worst pleas in HK history.

I get that chefs should be giving it their all, but to me, caring a 10 out of 10 is pretty much sacrificing everything for Hell's Kitchen, which makes me think of Michael (S11). He gave up watching the birth of his kid to go to HK, which was frowned upon my Chef Ramsay and the audience, so clearly people don't want chefs to sacrifice everything for this.

Even in a mematic way, it doesn't make sense, considering how high a 9 is. If someone says, they like something "like a 9" they generally have a string opinion on that thing, which is the opposite of what the original clip is supposedly meant to represent. Plus there are much worse pleas like when Scott (S7) says he'll fuck everyone over. or Tony (S6) saying he likes to make things taste good, both of which are infinitely more funny.

Maybe I'm just dumb, but I don't understand why so many gravitated to this plea out of all of them.