Who are you starting?

For context... 3rd season of an online dynasty. 10 users in the B1G Ten. Playing on default All-American for now.

I won the natty last season. Wanted some speed at QB to open up RPO reads and the QB run game in general. I run a lot of RPO's and "safe" routes but do attempt deep passes when I can.

I started the season with Gaines at QB - his speed, Field General and star development won me over. I'm 5 games in and I've thrown 10 tds to 5 ints and I'm completing 79% of my passes with Gaines. Of the 5 ints, 3 of them were completely my fault and the other 2 were the result of poor throws.

I went into practice mode and subbed Simons in and I must admit, he throws a better ball. I use revamped passing and all throwns that are normally yellow with Gaines were blue with Simons so that got me second guessing myself...

So who would you start???